All week my daughter has been looping Olivia Rodrigo’s jealousy, jealousy, a song about envy, comparison and the strange ache of looking at someone else’s life and briefly wondering whether yours would feel better if it looked more like theirs. She is still in primary school, and somehow she already recognises something it took me decades to understand: comparison does not simply measure us. It bends the mirror through which we see ourselves.
We know the sensation. Someone announces the promotion. Someone’s business takes off. Someone seems richer, happier, more certain, more successful. There is the small sting when another person appears to move ahead of us, occasionally followed by the equally uncomfortable lift when we realise we may be ahead of someone else. Then another person appears, the ranking changes again, and the internal calculation begins anew.
Social media industrialised this instinct by giving us an endless supply of people against whom to measure ourselves. Artificial intelligence is doing something stranger. It is not simply increasing the number of things available for comparison. It is beginning to destabilise the measuring system itself.
Human beings have always been intensely attuned to one another. Long before LinkedIn introduced job titles or Instagram introduced follower counts, our lives depended on understanding who belonged, who could be trusted, who held influence and where we fitted within the group. Psychologists describe part of this tendency through social comparison theory: we use other people as reference points for understanding our own abilities, opinions and standing.
There is nothing inherently unhealthy about this. Comparison can orient us. It can teach us. Someone else’s achievement can widen our sense of what is possible. But repeated often enough, comparison can stop being information about the world and become information about who we believe ourselves to be.
I am successful because I am ahead. I am intelligent because I can do something most people cannot. I am valuable because people need what I know. I matter because of where I sit.
Slowly, often without noticing, comparison becomes the signal and hierarchy becomes the story we build around it. Who is rising? Who is slipping? Who matters? Who has arrived? We construct these invisible hierarchies everywhere: inside organisations, industries, schools, neighbourhoods, friendship groups and professions.
I know what it feels like to build a self inside one.
At the height of my previous business, I was travelling around the country, speaking on stages and working alongside people I had admired for years. Externally, my world was expanding. There were new skills, new audiences, new opportunities and new levels of recognition. Internally, though, something quieter was happening. I was beginning to use altitude as evidence.
If I was on those stages, perhaps I mattered. If people wanted my expertise, perhaps I was becoming someone. If I was moving upward, perhaps I was safe.
I do not remember consciously thinking any of this. That is precisely the point. It was not arrogance so much as architecture. I had quietly built parts of my identity inside a hierarchy. And success inside a hierarchy can feel surprisingly similar to safety, which means falling through one does not simply feel like losing status. It can feel like losing yourself.
I discovered that when I left the business. A new project fell apart within months. A consulting process I had spent years refining was suddenly less in demand. Bigger players entered parts of the speaking market I knew well. Then generative AI began moving rapidly into writing, strategy, research and knowledge work, precisely the kinds of capabilities around which I had built much of my professional identity.
My external circumstances changed, but what hurt was deeper. I could no longer locate myself on the map. For several years I thought I was recovering from professional disappointment. Looking back, I think I was recovering from something more confronting.
I had mistaken my coordinates for my identity.
That is why the AI conversation feels so different from an ordinary conversation about technology. Artificial intelligence is not simply making some tasks faster. It is entering domains we have spent generations associating with intelligence, education, expertise and professional status: writing, analysis, coding, design, research and strategy.
That does not mean those professions simply disappear, nor does it mean human expertise has suddenly become irrelevant. What is changing is subtler.
The signal is becoming harder to read.
A beautifully written document once told us something about how well somebody could write. An elegant presentation told us something about their ability to synthesise. A sophisticated analysis implied a certain amount of knowledge, labour and experience. Increasingly, the relationship between the output and the human capability behind it is less obvious.
Someone with modest expertise and a powerful model can sometimes produce work that resembles the output of someone with years of experience. Meanwhile, someone with deep expertise can use exactly the same technology to extend their capability dramatically. The output remains. The assumptions beneath it change.
That is what makes this moment psychologically destabilising. AI does not need to eliminate your job in order to unsettle your identity. It only needs to become competent at something you believed proved who you were.
Imagine Daniel. He is forty-two and works in financial services. He is competent, reliable and experienced, the kind of person who knows what he is good at and roughly where he belongs. He has not lost his job. In many ways, AI has made him better at it. Research that once consumed an afternoon can be assembled in minutes. First drafts appear almost instantly. A system can generate ten strategic possibilities before a meeting has even begun.
He uses the technology. His productivity improves. Yet beneath that improvement sits a more uncomfortable question: if this used to be difficult, and difficulty was part of what made me valuable, what am I now?
Then he opens LinkedIn. Someone has launched a company. Someone else has published a book. Another person has apparently transformed their entire team with AI. Somebody has generated in a weekend what looks suspiciously like six months of work.
The feed tells him everyone is accelerating. The technology tells him everything can be accelerated. Somewhere between the two, his nervous system reaches an obvious conclusion: you are falling behind.
But behind what?
That may be one of the defining questions of this moment.
For most of human history, comparison had an important limitation. However extraordinary another person might have been, they were still human. They still slept. They still forgot things. They still occupied one body and one life. Now we can sit beside systems that produce language, images, analysis and ideas at a speed and scale no individual human being can match.
This is where finitude matters, but only briefly. Human beings are bounded creatures. Our attention, time and energy are limited. Yet the deeper issue is not limitation itself. It is what happens when we take an old human instinct for comparison and direct it towards systems operating according to entirely different rules.
If we use machine abundance as a new measure of human adequacy, we will almost certainly conclude that we are deficient. We will never read enough, know enough, produce enough, respond fast enough or generate enough.
The problem is not that humans are becoming inadequate.
The problem is that the unit of measurement has changed.
Once you see that, the whole idea of progress starts to look different.
We like vertical stories. More. Higher. Faster. Next. Winning. Arriving. Even personal development is often narrated as ascent. For decades, we represented Maslow’s ideas using a pyramid, despite the fact that Maslow himself never drew one. Perhaps that says as much about us as it does about psychology. We took a theory about human needs and turned it into a climb.
We do this with careers too. Junior. Senior. Director. Executive. Founder. Thought leader. We place success vertically and then quietly absorb the idea that becoming more means moving upward.
But life rarely behaves like that. We become experts and beginners at the same time. We become parents and discover entire territories in which competence cannot protect us. We succeed professionally while feeling lost personally. We lose things. We begin again. We become powerful in one room and helpless in another.
Sometimes becoming more fully ourselves looks nothing like ascending.
I misunderstood this for years. When my own pyramid collapsed, I assumed I had gone backwards. Now I wonder whether I had simply been returned to ground level.
And perhaps ground level is where identity becomes interesting.
When external measures become less reliable, another possibility opens. If a machine can produce beautiful writing, then beautiful writing alone cannot tell me what a writer is. If a system can generate a strategy, perhaps strategy is no longer simply the production of a document. If information is abundant, perhaps knowledge alone cannot be the thing around which we construct human worth.
AI forces us to separate the product from the person.
What I produce is not identical to who I am. What I know is not identical to my worth. How quickly I perform is not the measure of my life.
Once those ideas begin to loosen, a different question emerges. Not: how do I remain ahead? But: who am I when ahead and behind stop being useful coordinates?
That feels to me like one of the most important questions of the AI era.
Perhaps we need different ways of locating ourselves. Do I have agency in my life? Am I becoming capable at things that matter? Do I belong somewhere? Am I connected to people I love? Does the way I live resemble what I claim to value? Can I direct my attention rather than simply surrendering it? Can I contribute something meaningful to another person? Can I change my mind without losing myself?
None of those questions has a leaderboard.
Perhaps that is their strength.
I do not think comparison is going away, and I do not think hierarchy will suddenly disappear. Human beings will continue comparing themselves. Organisations will continue ranking people. Some capabilities will become more valuable while others lose their scarcity. Entirely new status systems will emerge.
But perhaps we can become more conscious of what we are asking those systems to tell us.
A job can tell me what I do. A salary can tell me what an organisation currently pays for it. An audience can tell me how much attention something received. A machine can tell me how quickly something can now be produced.
None of them can tell me what my life is worth.
That distinction becomes more important in a world saturated with systems capable of producing more, faster. There will always be more to know, more to make, more to optimise, more people apparently moving faster and more output arriving while we sleep.
We cannot win that contest by trying to become machines ourselves.
The invitation is not to abandon ambition. It is not to pretend achievement does not matter. It is not to retreat from technology or romanticise some simpler human past. It is to become far more careful about what we use as evidence of a meaningful life.
Intelligence is not the same thing as wisdom. Output is not the same thing as contribution. Visibility is not significance. Speed is not direction. Being surpassed at a task is not the same thing as becoming less valuable.
For years, I thought progress meant climbing.
Now I am beginning to wonder whether some of our most important growth begins when the ladder stops telling us where to go, when the old mirrors stop giving us reliable answers, and when the coordinates blur enough that we are forced to ask a much more interesting question:
Who do I want to become if there is nobody left to beat?
Perhaps that is not the collapse of identity.
Perhaps it is the beginning of authorship.
With love and curiosity,
Becs x

